Did NGC grade this coin correctly???

[LMCOIN 10]

Goodday

 

Please have a look at the following graded coin:

 

1894 ZAR 2 Shilling AU58

 

i do not have all the grading experience, but cannot see that this coin is even close to a XF grade.

 

What went wrong with the largest grading firm in the world here???

[coinoisseur 11]

Pretty simple. Poor Grading Service. Coin should not have even been graded

[PBGold 10]

Hi Anthony, is there any news regarding a Durban show this year?

[coinoisseur 11]

Hi PBGold, I am busy with planning for the show now and talking to sponsors. Possible date will be end April or Early to mid June. I will publish more details when I finalise everything.

[EWAAN Galleries 11]

NGC will pay you current market price for your coin

 

Goodday

 

Please have a look at the following graded coin:

 

1894 ZAR 2 Shilling AU58

 

i do not have all the grading experience, but cannot see that this coin is even close to a XF grade.

 

What went wrong with the largest grading firm in the world here???

 

Hi

 

All humans make mistakes... NGC does however offer to purchase the coin from you at market price or they will find you a coin and replace yours.....

 

But any grader can make an error - they only human!

 

 

See this link: NGC's coin grading guaranty for coin dealers.

[Pierre_Henri 27]

Hi

 

All humans make mistakes... NGC does however offer to purchase the coin from you at market price or they will find you a coin and replace yours.....

 

But any grader can make an error - they only human!

 

 

"ALL ANIMALS ARE EQUAL, BUT SOME ARE MORE EQUAL THAN OTHERS"

- George Orwell, Animal Farm, Ch. 10

Edited January 13, 2012 by Pierre_Henri

[LMCOIN 10]

Hi

 

I do understand all graders make mistakes, but this seems to be a massive mistake.

 

Showing this photo to one of the more knowledgable collectors the grade was given as VF-

 

This is not good. Any massive mistakes like this seen by other grading companies?

[EWAAN Galleries 11]

Hi

 

I do understand all graders make mistakes, but this seems to be a massive mistake.

 

Showing this photo to one of the more knowledgable collectors the grade was given as VF-

 

 

This is not good. Any massive mistakes like this seen by other grading companies?

 

 

 

Yes all Grading companies can make mistakes - BUT NGC is prepared to pay for their mistakes.......

[Guest Guest]

eBay - NGC part owned by major dealers and grading inconsistent

 

Source post linked at: http://forum.bidorbuy.co.za/coins-notes-numismatist/13813-south-african-numismatic-grading-service-s-n-g-s-6.html#post130589

 

Kind regards

 

Scott Balson

[Lukeness 10]

You have to remember that those guides are written by normal eBay members and there is no form of copy editing or fact checking.

[Cold Sea 3]

I have commented on this "error" before, where NGC grades a R5 coin medallic alignment. All our modern coins are medallic aligned or medal struck. Looking at this listing I've noticed two coins graded this way. The graders are obviously not familiar with South African coins.

Collections & Sets - kiNGCoin2008, GOT THE MOST RARE NELSON MANDELA SET?????? MAKE ME AN OFFER, I CAN'T RESIST??????? for sale in Durban (ID:54845614)

 

An assigned grade can still be debated, but this kind of mistake (twice!) is a bit iffy.

 

 

 

 

[geejay50 10]

Hi LM Coin,

 

Please can you upload close ups of the Obverse and a pic of the Reverse?

 

Geejay

[republikein 10]

In my humble opinion of the photo before me, there seems to be obvious hair lines present...

[ATOMICSQUIRREL 10]

That coin was prob graded on a Friday or a Monday heheh.:razz: