When is the Colour of a Coin Unnatural ??

[geejay50 10]

Hello Collectors,

This numismatic hobby is one of rare beauty and that is often the spark that keeps the fire of our passion going.

I have had this 1932 Halfcrown passed through NGC and PCGS with both companies refusing to grade it because of "Unnatural Colour"

We all know that the Copper component of Silver gives a variety of shades and gives to the metal silver attractive colours that make many coins unique.

We also know that coins have been doctored in various ways to bring out attractive colours and that artificial treatment needs to be identified by the third party grading company and excluded from accepted numismatics.

 

Third party graders are the corner stone of numismatics and without them we would not have an objective basis for evaluation. This posting in no ways pretends to diminish their standing.We all need them and they do an excellent job.

It is of interest though to use pictures to show what could be just very nice toning that is regarded as over the top. Some pics of a 1958 Brown Penny are also shown - it was a present and eventhough a duplicate, I treasure it as an example of how nice copper can get whatwith the differing pressures and heat used in striking Proofs that may favour production of pigmentary byproducts.

Regards

Geejay

 

 

[jwither 12]

I would agree that the 1932 2/6 does not look like any other SA silver coin I have seen, but I doubt that it was "doctored". The reason for this is that there either zero or a minimal premium versus a "white" coin.

[Little Miss Muffet 42]

I have a set of the wildlife series which ofcourse are gold plate on sterling silver and some of them have taken on that toning as well.

 

I am not sure but someone said these are ,1000 not the usual ,925

[Little Miss Muffet 42]

I have a set of the wildlife series which ofcourse are gold plate on sterling silver and some of them have taken on that toning as well.

 

I am not sure but someone said these are ,1000 not the usual ,925

Another one

[geejay50 10]

Hi Collectors,

Here is another very attractive and Unc ZAR 1892 Penny that was rejected as unnaturally toned by NGC.

I think the graders may have a point here.

 

 

 

Geejay

[geejay50 10]

Hi Collectors,

Here is a Penny that was acceptable to the graders and graded MS64. It has a striped and spotty black pattern that is unusual to copper.

Geejay

[geejay50 10]

Hello Colectors,

 

Here is a German East Africa Half Rupie 1913J (mtge 200,000) that was rejected by NGC for unnatural toning.

 

Its a scarce coin (Nil graded NGC & PCGS) and had an orange colour overall. By using Silverbrite (Pick n Pay), I removed the colour without affecting the lustre and left a normal looking coin behind.One only needs to dip and wipe gently with one's fingers (Eli Levine -'as gently as you wipe a baby's bottom')

 

Dont give up when NGC rejects. The coin may be salvageable.

 

Regards

 

Geejay

Edited May 3, 2011 by geejay50

[Saint786 10]

Hi All

Got this penny in a collection i purchased recently, love the pattern it has. A few of the

coppers in the collection have a similar effect.

[Saint786 10]

Included as well, was this blank penny.

Regards

Irfaan