Mandela Birthday Coin in Proof

[HR_COINS 10]

Hi Guys

 

Do you guys know how many birthday proofs were minted?

 

As far as I knew(which was wrong) there was none minted.

 

Check auction below

 

Graded - FINALLY HERE @@@ Mandela 90th Birthday R5 NGC PROOF 69 Ultra Cameo - First on Bid or Buy @ R1 Start for sale in Johannesburg

[BumbleBee 10]

I heard that there was a limited run of around 5000 minted, please could someone correct me if I'm wrong.

 

Ouchie on the price this this auction is getting

[Gecko Coins 10]

Hi

 

I am no Mandela expert, but some time back there was talk of some of the 2008 Birthday coins (In the case with the 2000 Mandela) that were sent to NGC for grading. These came back Proof although they were lazer frosted. NGC then requested that these be returned, but I guess that some did not return.

I may be wrong (not the first time) but these cannot have any value as there were never proof coins minted. Hern's does not make mention of them and would have if there were proofs minted. Someone is going to get their fingers burnt!!

 

Cheers

[EWAAN Galleries 11]

Hi

 

You can clearly see from the pictures that this is a proof coin. It is almost a perfect PF70 when looking at the coin itself.

 

This auction must be a record for bid or buy with over 1000 page views and 49 users tracking

 

Good Luck to the winning bidder

 

Regards,

 

EWAAN Auction Galleries

[HR_COINS 10]

The coin does look stunning Ewaan, my question was just how many proofs were minted and if possible when was these released........

 

Good luck to the winner. The coin looks amazing.

[Little Miss Muffet 37]

Hi

 

You can clearly see from the pictures that this is a proof coin. It is almost a perfect PF70 when looking at the coin itself.

 

This auction must be a record for bid or buy with over 1000 page views and 49 users tracking

 

Good Luck to the winning bidder

 

Regards,

 

EWAAN Auction Galleries

Just relating this to hubby. Never he says.

"So what do you think he paid for it" ?

My guess is as good as his.:rolleyes::confused:

[rvswartz 10]

HI there,

 

there were 5000 sets minted.

 

regards

[Gecko Coins 10]

HI there,

 

there were 5000 sets minted.

 

regards

 

Hi,

 

are you refering to the Mandela Commemorative R5 Set which sells for around R1000??

 

Those 2008 Mandela coins were all laser frosted and are not original proofs thus they cannot (or should I rather say "should not") be graded as proofs. Perhaps one of the experts on this forum can enlighten us,

 

regards

[coinoisseur 10]

Have a look at this link..........

 

http://forum.bidorbuy.co.za/coins-notes-numismatist/6761-mandela-90th-birthday-celebration-set.html

 

 

 

 

Cheers

[HR_COINS 10]

Thanks Anthony for that........

This is exactly what I was looking for.

This proof coin must have came from the set!

[inveco 10]

Hi

 

I think if we wait a while we might see these proof R5

Mandela 2008 coins CHEAPER than what they are being offered for now. Remember when the 2008 mandela R5 were offered for the first time people were paying alot more than what they are going for now.

 

2nd Point

 

If they were only released recently shoud they not grade

" In Retro Spect":confused: